Last night's experiment: New York strip steak with caramelized onions and sauteed mushrooms, split three ways. Since we're all college students, we had planned to buy a cheaper cut, but HyVee (a Midwest grocery store chain) was selling strip steaks for $5.99/lb. We got a bottle of Barefoot Merlot too.
The mushrooms and onions were the easy part. I bought three massive Vidalia onions, since the white and yellow onions available were less than ideal, cut them in half through the root end, and then sliced them about 1/4 inch thick. In a deep 14" saute pan, I heated about 4 tbsp of unsalted butter and a splash of canola oil over medium to medium-high heat. I added all of the onions, salt and pepper, and a sprinkle of brown sugar (in retrospect, unnecessary, but I'm not usually using sweet onions), and then stirred to coat everything. I let them cook for a bit, stirring frequently, until they were well-softened and starting to brown; then I turned the heat down and let them cook longer. Whenever the pan started to look dry, I added a few tablespoons of water to deglaze it. Finally, when they were dark brown and quite sticky, I took them off the heat. I added about 3 tbsp of butter to the onion pan, heated it until it had stopped foaming, and then poured in about 1.5 lbs of button mushrooms, sliced. I cooked those until they had stopped losing moisture, stirring regularly, and then combined the mushrooms and onions, tossing to coat everything with delicious caramelized onion juices.
The steak was a bit more difficult. I had two 8-oz steaks of approximately equal thickness, so I patted them dry and seasoned them on both sides with salt and pepper. I heated 2 tsp of olive oil in a cast-iron pan until smoking, and then added the steaks. I suspect that was my first mistake - adding two steaks caused a large temperature drop (I'm guessing) and so they didn't brown as quickly as necessary. I flipped them using forks, as we have no tongs in our apartment, and then stuck the whole pan into a 450-degree oven for 4 minutes. In my defense, the instructions I was semi-following said 3-5 minutes for rare, though obviously they meant a thicker steak, and my friends had asked for doneness ranging from "rare" to "medium-well".
Sadly, upon removing the steak, it became clear it had made it all the way to medium-well. It was still very tasty; dousing a bite of steak in mushrooms and onions made it acceptably juicy, the wine paired well with it, and the entire meal, including wine, only cost about $8 per person. I would have taken pictures, but we were all too busy eating. Plus, I'd prefer to document the experiment when the steak is appropriately red and juicy. With steak this inexpensive, though, I could probably try it once a week...which is awesome.
Sadly, upon removing the steak, it became clear it had made it all the way to medium-well. It was still very tasty; dousing a bite of steak in mushrooms and onions made it acceptably juicy, the wine paired well with it, and the entire meal, including wine, only cost about $8 per person. I would have taken pictures, but we were all too busy eating. Plus, I'd prefer to document the experiment when the steak is appropriately red and juicy. With steak this inexpensive, though, I could probably try it once a week...which is awesome.